10A+-+Justin

media type="youtube" key="mYGqOMe-DqQ" height="390" width="640"

This is a somewhat cheeky but nicely done video of the Purim story. It has very nice, colorful and creative graphics, well-done voiceovers, and kind of a fun Arabic-sounding music that doesn't overwhelm the video. (I often find that the music on similar-type videos is "too much.") The story is presented by Ester in first-person. There is a confusing element however: at the end of the video, there is a spotlight, followed by a stage curtain with a "Purim Carnival" sign over it. Nowehere at the beginning of the video is there any indication to the viewer that this is a Purim carnival play. What appeared to be a well-done summary was a show. It didn't detract from the message, but the ending is not consistant with the beginning.

As far as content, it is excellent overall. However, there is a line, when Esther is about to be presented to the King for the first time, when she sort of flippingly says, "I decided not to mention it" regarding her Judaism. Especially for children, there needs to be a little explanation as to why not. (Otherwise this could be seen to be condoning of intermarriage...too many Jews "decide not to mention it.") Of course there are all kinds of ways to explain this in the video, according to midrash, etc, but no explanation is given. That was the one thing that bothered me. (Although it may be possible that the kids wouldn't even notice.)

I loved the ending where Ester tells the audience to "Always have the courage to stand up for what you believe in." That is a great "take away" message for the kids...and, of course, is one of the main themes of Purim. The video is very clear in showing that Esther did exactly that, and that she was doing it for her whole people. A well-done video; one that is definately worth using.